Premier League clubs to cover legal fees if Man City sponsors sue over financial breaches
Premier League clubs have voted to cover the legal costs of the competition's board if Manchester City's sponsors take legal action against them. Etihad and Etisalat have indicated they are considering legal steps following the verdict that found the club guilty of financial rule breaches. The amendment passed with 18 votes in favour and two against.
Premier League clubs have approved a change to the competition's articles that will allow the league to fund the legal defence of its senior leadership if Manchester City's sponsors pursue legal action against them. The decision came at the first meeting of clubs since an independent commission found City guilty of all financial charges brought against them.
- The Premier League will cover legal costs for its board if Manchester City sponsors file lawsuits.
- Etihad and Etisalat have signalled they are considering legal action following the verdict against the club.
- The amendment passed with 18 votes in favour and two against, according to the BBC.
- The independent commission found City inflated commercial revenue by £830 million between 2009 and 2018.
- Manchester City have appealed the ruling and claim they hold irrefutable evidence of their innocence.
Clubs grant legal protection to Premier League directors
The vote, held at the first gathering of clubs since the verdict, drew support from 18 teams. Manchester City and Nottingham Forest were the two clubs to vote against the amendment, according to BBC Sport.
The change gives Premier League chief executive Richard Masters, along with four other board directors, stronger protections so they can carry out their duties without fear of legal exposure. Alongside Masters, the cover extends to chair Alison Brittain and non-executive directors Mai Fyfield, Dharmash Mistry and Matthew Ryder.
Why Etihad and Etisalat are weighing legal action
Etihad had already indicated in September that it was contemplating legal steps over the "damaging" impact of the independent commission's findings. Although the airline was not directly named in the ruling, the commission concluded that Manchester City used sham agreements to artificially boost revenue and hide expenses, breaching Premier League and UEFA financial regulations.
Days before the vote, The Times reported that Etisalat, another of the club's sponsors, was similarly assessing possible legal recourse. The amendment was framed as a move to modernise the league's personal legal protection and bring it in line with standard corporate practices at equivalent entities, including several of its own member clubs.
Articles untouched for more than three decades
The governing articles that have now been revised had remained unexamined since the Premier League was established in 1992. The amendment sets no upper limit on the potential financial liability individual teams could face under the updated provisions.
No wider discussion of the Manchester City case took place at the meeting, and no questions were raised on the matter beyond the vote on legal cover.
The verdict against Manchester City and the ongoing appeal
The independent commission found the club inflated its commercial revenue by £830 million between the 2009-10 and 2017-18 seasons. Manchester City have appealed the decision, arguing they hold an "irrefutable body of evidence" that proves their innocence. A sanction for the breaches has yet to be decided.
This disciplinary case, and this decision, are the most significant in Premier League history.
After the verdict, Masters said the club had "systematically broken Premier League rules for nearly a decade". He stressed that it is a key responsibility of the league to ensure the rules approved by the clubs themselves are upheld to protect the integrity of the competition, and said the league remains committed to moving swiftly through the remainder of the process.
What legal cover means for Premier League clubs
The approved measure goes beyond a direct response to possible sponsor lawsuits: it aims to update the league's governance framework. By shifting potential legal exposure from individual directors to the competition itself, the Premier League seeks to ensure its officials can act without personal financial risk when defending the integrity of the competition.
The fact that two clubs voted against shows the reform did not command unanimity, but the 18 votes in favour underline the dominant position among top-flight clubs.
Frequently asked questions
Why are Manchester City's sponsors considering legal action against the Premier League?
Etihad and Etisalat have signalled they are weighing legal steps over the impact of the independent commission's findings. The commission concluded the club used sham agreements to inflate revenue and hide expenses, which the sponsors see as damaging to their image.
Which clubs voted against the legal cover?
Manchester City and Nottingham Forest were the two clubs to vote against the amendment, according to BBC Sport. The other 18 Premier League clubs backed the change to the league's articles.
What sanction could Manchester City face?
A sanction has not yet been decided. The club have appealed the verdict and maintain they hold irrefutable evidence of their innocence, while the Premier League has said it is committed to moving swiftly through the rest of the process.