All news

Premier League records six referee errors in a single weekend, its joint-worst tally

The independent Key Match Incidents Panel has counted six on-field mistakes in the latest round of Premier League fixtures, the joint-highest number logged in one weekend since the early part of the 2023-24 season. Only two of those errors, according to the panel's votes, should have led to a VAR intervention.

InfoBlaugranaByInfoBlaugranaVerified account8 min read
A Premier League referee points to the penalty spot during a match in the latest round of fixtures.
A Premier League referee points to the penalty spot during a match in the latest round of fixtures.

The most recent round of Premier League matches produced a figure not seen since the start of the 2023-24 campaign. The Key Match Incidents Panel, the independent body that reviews contentious decisions every week, recorded six on-field refereeing errors across the weekend, matching the highest number it has logged in a single round. According to the panel's assessments, only two of those mistakes should have triggered a VAR intervention.

  • The Key Match Incidents Panel counted six on-field referee errors in one weekend, its joint-highest single-round total.
  • Two of those mistakes, involving Coventry City and Arsenal, should have led to a VAR correction.
  • Penalties awarded to Crystal Palace and Ipswich, plus an Everton goal, were among the decisions called incorrect but not clear enough for video review.
  • High-profile calls such as Jayden Bogle's challenge on Mathys Tel and a penalty for Sunderland were backed by the panel.

How the Key Match Incidents Panel votes on every decision

Each week, the five members of the Key Match Incidents Panel assess all the controversial situations from the latest round of fixtures and cast two separate votes. The first concerns the referee's on-field decision, judged against the laws of the game and the interpretation the Premier League expects from its officials. The second looks at whether the VAR should have intervened, taking into account what the referee said, the available replay angles and the high threshold for video corrections.

The figure of six errors does not include correct VAR interventions that fixed mistakes on the pitch. The red card shown to Brentford forward Igor Thiago after a video review was one such case, with the sending-off considered properly handled from the VAR room.

The two errors the VAR should have corrected

The panel was unanimous in identifying two incidents where the video assistant referee should have stepped in to overturn the referee's original call. In both cases, the vote was 5-0 against the on-field decision and 5-0 against the failure to intervene.

Tarkowski's pull on Yirenkyi inside the Coventry penalty area

During the match between Everton and Coventry City, Caleb Yirenkyi went down inside the box after a tangle with James Tarkowski. The referee waved play on and the VAR saw no reason to intervene. The panel concluded that Tarkowski had a hold of Yirenkyi's hair and that the incident should have been reviewed.

Tarkowski had a hold of Yirenkyi's hair and the panel unanimously felt that VAR should have intervened.

The foul on Kai Havertz that an offside call did not cancel out

In Arsenal's match, referee Farai Hallam was sent to the pitchside monitor by VAR Michael Oliver to review a possible penalty on Kai Havertz inside the Hull City area. Nobel Mendy had pulled down the Germany international, but the incident was ruled out because Havertz was judged to have been in an offside position. The panel disagreed with that interpretation.

Although Havertz is clearly in an offside position, there is a clear and impactful holding action by Mendy before any potential offside offence.

On-field mistakes that did not cross the VAR threshold

The panel also identified four further referee errors that did not meet the clear and obvious threshold required for a VAR review. As a result, they were logged as incorrect on the pitch but not counted as failures by the video assistant referee.

The first came in the game between Everton and Coventry City. Thierno Barry put Everton ahead in the 61st minute after a VAR check for a possible handball. Three of the five panel members felt the ball had accidentally struck Barry's hand, but the available footage did not offer conclusive evidence. The on-field vote was 3-2 against the decision, while all five agreed there should have been no VAR intervention.

Deep into stoppage time of Liverpool's match against Crystal Palace, the referee awarded a penalty to the home side for a foul by Milos Kerkez on Dario Osorio. The panel ruled that the penalty was incorrect because the contact was inevitable, but did not consider it a clear and obvious mistake requiring a video review.

In the meeting between Ipswich and Bournemouth, the official gave Ipswich a 72nd-minute penalty for a foul by Lewis Cook on Abdoul Ouattara. Four of the five panel members felt Ouattara had clearly stepped across Cook, who did not make a challenge, making the award incorrect. The vote on whether the VAR should have intervened was 4-1 against.

The fourth mistake related to a potential second yellow card for Bournemouth's Marcus Tavernier. Three panel members believed there was a clear, deliberate action by the player to delay the restart, although no VAR intervention was possible in that situation.

The controversial calls the panel did back

Some of the weekend's most high-profile incidents survived the panel's scrutiny without being marked as errors. Jayden Bogle's challenge on Tottenham's Mathys Tel, which led to a formal complaint from the London club, was one of them. Spurs argued that Bogle should have been sent off, but the panel voted 3-2 that the decision not to show a red card was correct, reasoning that the challenge lacked the speed, force or intensity to be considered serious foul play. Two panel members saw it as dangerous enough to warrant a dismissal.

On the possible penalty for Chelsea when Cole Palmer went down under a challenge from Luke O'Nien, the panel backed the on-field call by 4-1, judging that the contact was made outside the area. One member felt the foul had occurred inside. Similarly, the penalty awarded to Sunderland for Levi Colwill's trip on Brian Bobbey was supported unanimously, with the panel noting upper-body holding from both players before the Chelsea defender's careless challenge.

Patrick Dorgu's 96th-minute equaliser for Aston Villa also came through the review process without being flagged. The panel examined a possible foul by Senne Lammens on goalkeeper Zion Suzuki in the build-up, but all five members agreed the contact was not impactful enough to rule out the goal.

Why these rulings matter for Premier League referees

The panel's work carries real consequences. Its weekly results feed into a merit table that determines half of the bonus payments received by Premier League referees, directly linking performance assessments to a significant portion of their income. The system is specific to the English top flight. The Scottish Premiership scrapped a similar panel last summer after clubs grew frustrated with the voting patterns of its members.

Many fans will feel that two VAR errors in a single round is a low count given the number of contentious incidents across the weekend. But the panel does not exist to mirror supporter opinion. It applies the laws of the game and the standards the Premier League sets for its referees. Even so, six on-field mistakes in one round, plus the Thiago red card that was corrected from the video room, paints a difficult picture for the officiating body over that weekend.

Frequently asked questions

How many referee errors did the panel find in the latest Premier League weekend?

The Key Match Incidents Panel recorded six on-field referee errors in the latest round of fixtures, matching the highest single-weekend tally since the early part of the 2023-24 season. Of those six, only two were deemed serious enough to require a VAR intervention.

Which incidents should the VAR have reviewed according to the panel?

The panel unanimously flagged two incidents: James Tarkowski's hair pull on Caleb Yirenkyi inside the Coventry City penalty area and Nobel Mendy's foul on Kai Havertz in Arsenal's match, which was ruled out for an offside that the panel felt did not cancel the holding offence.

Do the panel's rulings affect Premier League referees financially?

Yes. The weekly results from the Key Match Incidents Panel contribute to a merit table that accounts for 50% of the bonus payments received by Premier League referees, tying performance reviews to a major part of their variable income.

Based on reporting by BBC Sport.