Premier League reviews its most controversial VAR weekend: two to four possible errors
The latest Premier League matchday produced a flood of contentious VAR decisions, from disallowed goals and penalty appeals to a red card that has split opinion among former players. The independent panel that assesses key match incidents could add between two and four errors to its list, after recording only two in the first eight rounds.

The Premier League went through a weekend full of disputed refereeing decisions, with VAR at the centre of almost every match. After eight rounds in which the independent Key Match Incidents panel had detected only two errors, compared with six at the same stage last season, the latest matchday threatens to double that figure at once. Manchester United drew 4-4 with Aston Villa in stoppage time, Arsenal were denied a penalty they felt they deserved, and a red card for violent conduct opened a debate among former players.
- The KMI panel could add between two and four VAR errors in a single matchday.
- Manchester United rescued a 4-4 draw against Aston Villa with a 96th-minute goal that survived review.
- Arsenal and Coventry had penalty appeals that, according to the analysis, should have been given.
- Igor Thiago's red card for a blow to the head has divided opinion among specialists.
- An Everton goal by Thierno Barry raised doubts over a possible handball in the build-up.
Manchester United's draw with Aston Villa under VAR scrutiny
Manchester United avoided defeat in added time through a goal from Patrick Dorgu in the 96th minute that VAR checked for a possible foul by Senne Lammens on Aston Villa goalkeeper Zion Suzuki. The incident echoed a goal Arsenal scored at Old Trafford last season, when William Saliba leaned into goalkeeper Altay Bayındır. This time Lammens was not looking at the ball, which increased the chances of a VAR intervention. Even so, with the higher bar for correcting on-field decisions in England and minimal contact, the panel is unlikely to class it as a VAR error.
The other incident in the match came in the 16th minute, when the referee awarded Manchester United a penalty for a challenge by Boubacar Kamara on Matheus Cunha. Replays showed the Villa defender made contact with the Brazilian's foot before touching the ball. The panel should confirm the decision as correct.
The penalty Arsenal were not given against Hull
Arsenal left their match against Hull without a spot-kick even though Kai Havertz was pulled down inside the area by Nobel Mendy. VAR, led by Michael Oliver, sent referee Farai Hallam to the pitchside monitor, but the penalty was not awarded because the German forward had been offside. The interpretation of the sequence is key: the foul occurred before any potential offside offence, so the penalty should have been given. Although rewarding an offside attacker may feel wrong, the law supports the award and the panel is likely to log it as a mistake.
The Omar Bogle challenge that split opinion
In the Leeds game against Tottenham, Omar Bogle brought down Mathys Tel with a painful challenge that referee John Brooks punished with a free-kick but no card. VAR Tony Harrington decided not to send the official to the monitor to consider a red card. The difficulty lies in the fact that Bogle caused the contact with his supporting foot rather than the one challenging for the ball. The panel will have to decide whether it was an unfortunate incident or a tackle that endangered the opponent, a question that has divided former players and will depend on who sits on the committee this week.
The three Everton - Coventry incidents: hair pulling, edge-of-the-box contact and a doubtful handball
Coventry claimed a penalty after James Tarkowski appeared to pull the hair of Caleb Yirenkyi inside the area. The interpretation of hair pulling was relaxed this season, meaning it would not have led to a red card, but the footage shows a clear yank by the Everton defender. The panel could mark it as an incorrect decision and award a spot-kick.
Mykolenko's contact and Barry's goal
Coventry also appealed for another penalty after Vitalii Mykolenko clipped Taiwo Awoniyi. Replays place the contact just before the line of the area, so the decision not to award a spot-kick should be considered correct. More doubts surrounded Thierno Barry's goal in the 61st minute, which put Everton ahead and was checked for a possible handball. VAR determined there was no conclusive evidence, although the ball's direction appeared to change. Without the super-zoom tool, which takes several minutes to calibrate and is not available instantly, the panel could support the non-intervention and may even return a split vote.
Igor Thiago's red card and Crystal Palace's stoppage-time penalty
Brentford forward Igor Thiago was sent off after a VAR review for catching Chema Andres in the head with his forearm. The player can consider himself unfortunate, as there is doubt over whether he truly intended to strike the Spaniard in the face. Still, the VAR intervention is likely to be supported because the law states that a blow to the head should be punished with a red card unless the force is negligible. Thiago will miss three Premier League matches.
In stoppage time at Crystal Palace, the referee awarded a penalty for a foul by Milos Kerkez on Dario Osorio in the 93rd minute. The incident recalls William Saliba's challenge on Joao Pedro in the 2024-25 season, which the panel voted as a correct penalty decision, although this clash looks more evenly balanced. It could be marked as an on-field error, but without reaching the threshold required for a VAR intervention.
Other reviews: Palmer, Fulham and a disallowed Newcastle goal
Cole Palmer went down on the edge of the area under pressure from Luke O'Nien and Jules Ahoka and appealed for a penalty, but referee Jarred Gillett gave nothing. A foul is determined by the first contact on the attacker: falling into the box afterwards, with the contact already started, does not make it a spot-kick. Only in holding offences is continued contact relevant. The panel is likely to support the decision.
Newcastle had a goal disallowed at Craven Cottage for a foul by Yoane Wissa on Timothy Castagne. The visiting manager looked perplexed in his post-match interview, although he would probably have reacted furiously had a Fulham player held back one of his defenders to create a clear route for another attacker to score. The panel should vote this as a correct decision.
How many errors the KMI panel could confirm
The analysis points to two decisions the independent panel is very likely to record as VAR errors: the penalties not awarded to Arsenal and Coventry. Two further calls, Barry's goal and the possible red card for Bogle, could be added depending on the subjective view of the committee. The rest of the reviewed actions appear to be correct. If between two and four errors are confirmed, it would represent a bad weekend for video refereeing after a statistically solid start to the season.
Frequently asked questions
How many VAR errors have been recorded in the Premier League this season?
Before this weekend, the independent Key Match Incidents panel had recorded only two VAR errors in the first eight rounds. At the same stage last season, six mistakes had been logged.
Why were Arsenal not given a penalty against Hull?
Kai Havertz was brought down inside the area, but the referee did not award the spot-kick because the forward was offside. According to the analysis of the incident, the foul happened before the offside offence, so the penalty should have been given.
How many matches will Igor Thiago miss after his red card?
The Brentford forward was shown a red card for violent conduct after catching Chema Andres in the head with his forearm. The dismissal carries a three-match Premier League suspension.